Walking vs Running for Weight Loss: Which Is Better?

Walking vs running for weight loss — it's one of the most common fitness questions, and the answer is more nuanced than "running burns more calories, so running wins." The best exercise for weight loss is the one you'll actually do consistently, and that calculation looks different for every person.

Here's a complete, honest comparison of walking and running for weight loss: calorie burn, fat loss mechanisms, sustainability, injury risk, and how to choose the right approach based on your current fitness level.

Calorie Burn: Walking vs Running

Running burns more calories per minute than walking. That's simply physics — it requires more energy to move your body faster. But per mile traveled, the difference is smaller than most people expect.

Calories Burned Per Hour

Activity	Speed	130 lbs	155 lbs	185 lbs	215 lbs
Walking	3.5 mph	224	267	318	370
Brisk Walking	4.0 mph	275	328	391	455
Jogging	5.0 mph	413	472	563	654
Running	6.0 mph	511	590	704	817
Running	7.5 mph	628	738	880	1,022

Running at 6 mph burns roughly twice as many calories per hour as walking at 3.5 mph. But most people can't sustain running for an hour — especially beginners.

Calories Burned Per Mile

Here's where it gets interesting. Per mile covered, walking and running are much closer:

Activity	Calories per Mile (155 lbs)
Walking (3.5 mph)	~76
Brisk Walking (4.0 mph)	~82
Jogging (5.0 mph)	~94
Running (6.0 mph)	~98

The difference per mile is only about 15–25% — far less than the hourly difference suggests. This is because walking and running the same distance uses similar total muscle mass, just at different rates.

Use our Walking Calories Calculator to see your exact numbers based on your weight and pace.

The EPOC Factor: Running's Afterburn Advantage

Running has a physiological edge that walking doesn't: EPOC (Excess Post-Exercise Oxygen Consumption), often called the "afterburn effect."

After an intense run, your body continues burning calories at an elevated rate for 15 minutes to several hours as it:

• Restores oxygen levels in muscles
• Clears lactic acid
• Repairs muscle tissue
• Returns core temperature to normal

Studies suggest EPOC adds 6–15% more calories burned on top of the workout itself for vigorous exercise like running. For walking, EPOC is minimal.

What this means in practice: A 30-minute run might burn 350 calories during the workout and an additional 30–50 calories in the hours afterward. A 30-minute walk burns about 150 calories during and essentially no afterburn.

That said, EPOC from a moderate run is often overstated in popular media — it rarely exceeds 50–100 additional calories per session.

Fat Burning: Which Exercise Hits Fat Stores Harder?

Walking operates primarily in the "fat-burning zone" — a moderate heart rate range (50–70% of max) where the body relies predominantly on fat as fuel. Running at higher intensities shifts the fuel mix toward carbohydrates.

This leads to the counterintuitive question: does burning more fat per calorie (walking) or burning more total calories (running) lead to greater fat loss?

The answer: total calories burned wins. Research consistently shows that total energy expenditure drives fat loss more than the fuel mix used during exercise. However, walking's ability to sustain longer sessions without fatigue often makes it competitive with running over time.

For weight loss context, also see our guides on calories burned walking by time and distance and walking for weight loss: how many steps you need.

Sustainability: The Weight Loss Factor Nobody Talks About Enough

Here's a reality check: the best exercise for weight loss is the one you'll actually do for months and years, not just the one that burns the most calories in a 30-minute session.

Walking Sustainability Advantages

• Low injury risk: Walking has an injury rate of approximately 1–5% compared to 20–79% for running (research varies widely, but runners consistently experience far more injuries)
• No recovery needed: You can walk daily without overtraining or needing rest days for muscles to recover
• Accessible to all fitness levels: No fitness baseline required — anyone can start walking today
• Easy to accumulate throughout the day: Steps from commuting, errands, and daily life all count toward your total
• Lower perceived effort: Walking feels sustainable as a permanent lifestyle change, not a temporary program

Running Sustainability Advantages

• More time-efficient: You can burn the same calories in half the time compared to walking
• Greater fitness improvements: Running improves VO2 max and cardiovascular fitness faster
• Psychological rewards: Many runners report a stronger "runner's high" and sense of accomplishment
• More flexibility in scheduling: A 30-minute run accomplishes what might take 60 minutes of walking

The Consistency Math

Consider two people over 12 weeks:

• Person A (runner): Runs 3x per week, burns 400 calories per session, but takes 2 weeks off for a knee injury = 10 weeks × 3 sessions × 400 cal = 12,000 calories burned
• Person B (walker): Walks every day, burns 200 calories per session, zero missed days = 84 days × 200 cal = 16,800 calories burned

The consistent walker burned 40% more calories over the same period — despite a "less efficient" exercise. Consistency beats intensity every time.

Injury Risk Comparison

Injury risk is one of the most important factors in choosing between walking and running, especially if you're carrying extra weight or returning from a long sedentary period.

Injury Type	Walking Risk	Running Risk
Knee pain	Low	High (runner's knee)
Shin splints	Very low	Common in new runners
Stress fractures	Rare	More common
Plantar fasciitis	Low	Moderate
Hip injuries	Low	Moderate
Overall injury rate	~1–5%	~20–40%

If you're 20+ pounds over your goal weight, starting with running can create significant joint stress. Building a walking base first — reducing weight and building fitness — before transitioning to running is a medically sound approach.

Which Should You Choose? A Decision Framework

Choose Walking If:

• You're new to regular exercise or returning after a long break
• You have joint issues, previous injuries, or chronic pain
• You prefer low-impact, sustainable daily activity
• Your primary goal is health maintenance, not rapid calorie burn
• You want to accumulate steps throughout the day rather than scheduled workouts
• You're significantly overweight and want to protect your joints while losing weight

Choose Running If:

• You're already physically fit with a good aerobic base
• You have limited time and need efficient calorie burn
• You enjoy the challenge and intensity of running
• Your joints can handle the higher impact
• You respond well to structured workout schedules
• You want to improve cardiovascular fitness more rapidly

Consider Combining Both:

Many people find the best results with a mixed approach:

• Walk daily as a baseline (7,000–10,000+ steps)
• Add 2–3 runs per week as you build fitness
• Use walking as active recovery on non-running days
• Transition to run/walk intervals if running is your goal

Our Weight Loss Walking Calculator can help you calculate exactly how many steps and calories you need to hit your weight loss targets.

Practical Weight Loss Recommendations

For beginners: Start walking. Aim for 7,000–10,000 steps per day, every day. Build the habit before worrying about intensity. After 4–6 weeks of consistent walking, you can introduce walk-run intervals if you want to progress.

For intermediate exercisers: Combine 5–6 days of walking (maintaining a 10,000+ step daily baseline) with 2–3 runs per week. This maximizes total weekly calorie burn while keeping injury risk manageable.

For experienced runners: Keep running for time efficiency, but don't underestimate walking's contribution. A 10,000-step daily walking baseline adds 300–500 calories per day on top of your running calories.

For step-based weight loss planning, also check our walking to lose weight chart for a data-driven view of steps vs. pounds lost over time.

FAQ: Walking vs Running for Weight Loss

Does walking or running burn more fat?

Running burns more total fat per session because it burns more total calories. While walking uses a higher percentage of fat as fuel, running's higher total calorie burn means more total fat is metabolized. For weight loss, total calories burned is the more important variable.

Can you lose the same amount of weight walking vs running?

Yes, if total calories burned and dietary habits are equal. A person who walks consistently every day can achieve the same weight loss as someone who runs 3 times a week, especially accounting for the lower injury and burnout risk of walking.

Is walking 5 miles better than running 2 miles for weight loss?

A 155-pound person walking 5 miles burns about 380–430 calories. Running 2 miles burns roughly 200 calories. So yes — in this case, the longer walk burns more total calories than the shorter run. Distance matters as much as speed.

What happens to your body when you walk every day for 30 days?

Most people notice improved energy, better mood, potential weight loss (especially if diet hasn't changed), lower resting heart rate, and better sleep within 30 days of consistent daily walking. See our benefits of walking everyday post for a full breakdown.

Should I walk or run on a treadmill to lose weight?

Both are effective on a treadmill. Set the incline to 1% when walking to account for the lack of wind resistance and match outdoor conditions. For calorie burn, incline walking (3.5 mph at 5–8% incline) can match jogging on flat ground.

Is it okay to walk instead of run?

Completely. Walking is a legitimate, science-backed exercise for weight loss, cardiovascular health, and longevity. You don't need to run to be healthy. Walking is especially valuable for long-term consistency and joint health.

Get Started: Track Your Calories and Steps

Whether you choose walking, running, or a combination, accurate tracking helps you understand what's working and stay motivated.

Use these free tools to support your weight loss journey:

• Walking Calories Calculator — Calculate exactly how many calories your walks burn
• Weight Loss Walking Calculator — Find your step target for your specific weight loss goal
• Daily Step Goal Calculator — Set a personalized daily step goal

---

Track both your walks and runs in one place. Download the Steps app to automatically count steps, log workouts, track calories burned, and monitor weekly progress — free for iPhone and Apple Watch.